Penicillin Allergy and Superbugs


    Penicillin Allergy and Superbugs


    Penicillin allergy is a common finding in many patient charts.  Sometimes it can be difficult to figure out who, when and why this label was added to a medical record.  Sometimes patients themselves perpetuate the label, unwittingly reporting something a parent told them about a possible reaction as a child, or mistaking side effects for a reaction.  Either way, taking care of one patient with anaphylaxis is enough to strike fear into the heart of any prescriber.


    A true allergy can be a dangerous issue and should, of course, be taken seriously.  However, up to 95% of people who report an allergy to penicillin are not actually allergic when they undergo formal allergy testing.


    When patients for whom penicillin (or a member of the penicillin family) is the most appropriate choice report an allergy, providers are forced to make another selection.  This generally means moving to a broader spectrum antibiotic, which, unfortunately, puts patients at a higher risk for developing antibiotic resistant infections, like MRSA, and health care associated infections, like C. Diff.


    A matched cohort study of 11.1 million patients in the UK from June 2018 (see reference below) sought to compare the risk of MRSA and C. diff in patients with a documented penicillin allergy.  After adjusting for risk factors for both MRSA and C. diff, patients with a penicillin allergy were found to have a 69% increased risk of infection with MRSA, and a 26% increased risk of infection with C. diff.


    Less than 0.1% of patients who report a penicillin allergy receive formal testing.  As ED physicians, we can help by asking specific questions about reactions and updating charts, as well as providing patients with the allergy clinic contact info to find out for sure if their allergy is real.



    Risk of meticillin resistant Staphylococcus aureus and Clostridium difficile in patients with a documented penicillin allergy: population based matched cohort study.  BMJ. 2018 Jun 27;361:k2400. doi: 10.1136/bmj.k2400.

    • Welcome! This is the website for the Mount Sinai Emergency Ultrasound Division. It serves as an information resource for residents, fellows, medical students and others seeking information about point-of-care ultrasound. There is a lot ofRead more

    • It’s Freezing!

      You are at elmhurst in the cardiac room. It is FREEZING outside. The triage nurse tells you there is a frequent flier in triage, EMS found him sleeping on the street with +AOB. He isRead more

    • pediatric blood transfusion

      So you’re in peds and your patient is anemic. You need to transfuse, but you are confused. How much blood do you give? How fast do you give it? How much: The volume of bloodRead more

    • Spontaneous Pneumomediastinum

      Your patient is a 24 yo M with chest pain.  It is pleuritic. He has normal vitals and you’re not too concerned. You get a CXR and you see the result in this post. HeRead more

    • In flight emergencies and when to land the plane

      You are on a flight, halfway across the Atlantic Ocean at the start of a much needed vacation, binge watching that new show everyone has been talking about but you’ve never had time to see. Read more

    • PE risk stratification: which tool is best?

        Your patient with a newly diagnosed PE hates hospitals.  He or she agrees to defer to your judgement about admission versus discharge home, but makes it clear they would prefer to go home ifRead more

    • Proper cane use

      We give out canes like they’re candy.  But are we doing a good job adjusting the cane and teaching patients how to use them?  Canes that are not the right height for your patient orRead more

    • Do antivirals or steroids help make shingles better?

      A patient comes to the emergency department reporting a few days of excruciating pain in a band around his right chest.  Today, he developed vesicles over the same area which prompted him to come in.Read more

    • Double Sequence No-no???

        You are the leader of the code team.  Your patient is in refractory VF after multiple rounds of shocks and drugs.  You’ve tried repositioning the pads into an anterior-posterior position.  Looking around, you askRead more