Paper Review: Are we hurting patients via oxygen supplementation?

    NextPrevious

    Paper Review: Are we hurting patients via oxygen supplementation?

    Bottom line up front: A recent large, high quality meta-analysis reported a significant mortality effect with the use of liberal, rather than conservative, oxygen supplementation. The number needed harm for 30-day mortality was 1 in 126. A modest but relevant NNH given how common oxygen supplementation is in the ER. Consider titrating all forms of oxygen supplementation – whether it be NC, NPPV or invasive ventilation – to a SpO2 of 94-96%.

     

    Background: Oxygen supplementation is ubiquitous in the practice of modern medicine. A recent large meta-analysis published in Lancet, the Improving Oxygen Therapy in Acute-illness (IOTA) review, called into question the use of liberal oxygen supplementation.

    Methods: The study combined the findings of 25 RCTs comparing liberal v conservative O2 supplementation across a wide spectrum of illnesses (ACS, stroke, sepsis, critical illness and emergency surgery). Patients were excluded if they had chronic pulmonary disease, required hyperbaric therapy or ECMO. Primary study endpoints were mortality measured at various time points. Secondary endpoints included length of hospital stay and rates of hospital acquired infection.

    Results: The 25 RCTs included a total of 16,037 patients. Median oxygen supplementation levels were fraction of inspired oxygen (FiO2) 0.52 vs. 0.21 (liberal vs. conservative). Authors found that liberal oxygen supplementation increased in-hospital mortality with a RR 1.21 (95% CI 1.03-1.43 ; NNH 1 in 137) and 30-day mortality with a RR 1.14 (95% CI 1.01-1.28 ; NNH 1 in 126). There were no significant differences in any of the secondary endpoints.

    Study Strengths:

    1. Solely reliant on data from RCTs.
    2. Large number of patients over a wide spectrum of disease.
    3. Exclusion of pts with chronic pulmonary disease. We can’t blame these findings on inadvertent blunting of the hypoxic respiratory drive that we observe in COPDers.
    4. There are few study endpoints as meaningful as mortality.
    5. The authors demonstrated a dose-response relationship between SpO2 and increased mortality above SpO2 of 96%.
    6. Findings were robust to multiple sensitivity analyses.

    Study Limitations:

    1. Authors fail to elicit or hypothesize the mechanism by which hyperoxemia causes harm. The authors allude to animal studies suggesting that oxidative stress increases risk for acute lung injury and excess oxygen promotes harmful vasoconstriction. However, it is equally plausible that liberal oxygen supplementation simply leads to delayed recognition of clinical decompensation.
    2. Authors provided limited commentary on subgroup analyses. The authors demonstrate some benefit to liberal oxygen therapy in reducing infection in the peri-operative setting, which is consistent with findings in prior papers. Unfortunately, the authors gloss over these findings in an effort to push forth their hypothesis. Furthermore, the authors provide limited commentary on the potential benefits of hyperoxemia in salvaging the penumbra for stroke patients.
    3. Authors do not differentiate between various types of O2 supplementation (eg, NC v NPPV v invasive ventilation).

    Conclusion: Conservative O2 therapy > liberal O2 therapy. Titrate supplemental O2 to SpO2 94-96%. This is an active area of research and more papers are likely to come.

    Source:

    Chu DK, Kim L, et al. Mortality and morbidity in acutely ill adults treated with liberal versus conservative oxygen therapy (IOTA): a systematic review and meta-analysis. Lancet. Vol 391, Issue 10131, p 1693-1705, Apr 28, 2018.

    • Welcome! This is the website for the Mount Sinai Emergency Ultrasound Division. It serves as an information resource for residents, fellows, medical students and others seeking information about point-of-care ultrasound. There is a lot ofRead more

    • renal handling of water

      If you were on a tea & toast diet, how much water would you need to drink before you develop hyponatremia? I haven’t seen anyone work out the numbers before so here are my calculations. AndRead more

    • acute acidemia physiology

      As alluded to in the first post, don’t be fooled by a “normal” potassium in the setting of DKA because osmotic diuresis and H+/K+ exchange means that total body potassium is actually LOW. You all knowRead more

    • renal handling of potassium

      the first symptom of hyperkalemia is death Earlier post covered temporizing measures to counter hyperkalemia — namely, intracellular shift, increasing cardiac myocyte threshold potential. Give furosemide if the patient still urinates and consider dialysis, but then askRead more

    • bicarbonate revisited

      Previous post reviewed the safety of balanced crystalloids in hyper K. But what was up with serum bicarbonate decreasing with saline administration? This post introduces a new way of looking at the anion gap to possiblyRead more

    • hyperkalemia and balanced crystalloids

      Is it safe to give LR or plasmalyte to a hyperkalemic patient (these balanced crystalloids have 4-5 mEq/L K as opposed to 0 mEq/L K in normal saline)? Postponing the discussion of renal handling of potassium toRead more

    • hyperkalemia physiology

      You’ll likely encounter hyperkalemia on your next Resus / Cardiac shift, and you’ll instinctively treat it. But take a moment to review the fascinating physiology behind the “cocktail”! First, consider how K+ is buffered byRead more

    • Slow down your tachycardia (but not really)

      You’re sitting in resus bemoaning the departure of your most beloved attending when suddenly a patient wheels in without warning. The patient looks relatively stable but the triage RN tells you her heart rate wasRead more

    • Otitis externa: use the ear wick!

      Acute otitis externa (AOE) is a common complaint seen in pediatric as well as adult emergency departments. AOE is typically not accompanied by acute otitis media, although concurrent cases are possible. Also called “swimmer’s ear”Read more

    NextPrevious