EFAST vs CXR for PTX

    Surgical resident X: “We have to get the chest X-ray before we go to CT.”

    EM resident Y: “Honestly, [surgical colleague X], I don’t think we do. The FAST didn’t have any evidence of pneumothorax, so I think we’re safe to proceed to the CT scanner rather than wait for X-ray right now.”

    Surgical resident X: “We always get the chest X-ray before we leave the trauma room.”

    EM resident Y (not interested in a fight): “Ok.”


    Not time to buck hundreds of years of tradition unimpeded by progress (and there are some other, less important, reasons for a chest X-ray on trauma patients), but it begs the question, which is better for detecting the pneumothorax in a trauma patient? We know it’s not our own ears (though you should listen, and will likely detect a larger collapsed lung this way), but is CXR or EFAST more sensitive for pneumothorax?

    The way I asked the question, you may already know it’s the EFAST Exam. Several studies have looked at this concept, but one of the more cited ones shows the following relative sensitivities and specificities. Do a good job of doing the EFAST, and you’ll be doing a good job to identify this immediately relevant pathology in your trauma patients. Don’t skip the chest X-ray (not just yet), but be knowledgeable about just how much it’s helping (probably not much) and how much false reassurance it may be adding (could be substantial). 

    Sensitivity Specificity
    EFAST Ultrasound 86-98% 97-100%
    Supine AP Chest X-ray 28-75% 100%


    Need a review on ultrasound detection of pneumothorax? Check this REBEL EM article, this emDOCs article, these 5-minute sono videos, or this Ultrasound Podcast video.

    • Welcome! This is the website for the Mount Sinai Emergency Ultrasound Division. It serves as an information resource for residents, fellows, medical students and others seeking information about point-of-care ultrasound. There is a lot ofRead more

    • Central Line Wizardry

      I was scrolling through twitter this morning when I came across a quick video from @CriticalCareNow for an awesome central line trick. And then I went to his feed and found some more. They areRead more

    • Let’s wait for the “official urinalysis”….?

      Chances are you order a urine dip or urinalysis on a good number of your patients each shift. But how good are these tests at helping us diagnose a urinary tract infection? The short answer:Read more

    • National Physician Suicide Awareness Day

      This past Tuesday (September 17th) was the first annual National Physician Suicide Awareness Day. CORD, ACEP, SAEM and a number of other EM organizations paired with organization from other specialties to raise awareness of theRead more

    • M is for morphine

      Remember MONA (morphine, oxygen, nitro, aspirin) from med school? Well, she may be just “A” now…. Over the years, all of these treatments (except for good old aspirin) have become somewhat controversial in the treatmentRead more

    • Meningitis Prophylaxis

      Have you ever taken care of really critical, undifferentiated patient, only later to find out that they were diagnosed with a serious, contagious illness? We are exposed to innumerable pathogens each day in the ED,Read more

    • The Betel Nut: an oral carcinogen

      Ever walk up to a stable, comfortable appearing patient at Elmhurst and their mouth/teeth are completely RED? Or maybe like a dark brownish/black color? Like this?? It really scared me the first I saw itRead more

    • The Fascia Iliaca compartment block: as magical as it sounds!

      In case you haven’t gotten to this month’s EM:RAP, there’s a really great segment on an important ED procedure that we definitely don’t do enough of in the ED: the nerve block. The section discussesRead more

    • Hurry Up & RUSH!

      You’re working in RESUS, and you get a notification for hypotension. He’s a 65 year old male noted to be hypotensive to 70/40 by EMS. On arrival, he’s altered and unable to provide any history,Read more