High Flow Nasal Cannula Better Than Conventional Therapy


    High Flow Nasal Cannula Better Than Conventional Therapy

    High-Flow Nasal Cannula for Avoiding Intubation?


    Citation: Ni YN, Luo J, Yu H, et al. Can high-flow nasal cannula reduce the rate of endotracheal intubation in adult patients with acute respiratory failure compared with conventional oxygen therapy and noninvasive positive pressure ventilation? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Chest. 2017


    What We Already Know: High flow nasal cannula (HFNC) may be beneficial in hypoxemic respiratory failure and is well-tolerated. A meta-analysis by Monro-Somerville et al has compared HFNC and usual care (i.e. nasal cannula or non-invasive ventilation) to find no difference in mortality or intubation.1 Furthermore, HFNC improves dyspnea and comfort scores.


    Why This Study is Important: Current practice in the ED is to consider techniques of delayed sequence intubation (DSI) to enable tolerance of non-invasive ventilation (NIV). This meta-analysis provides a non-inferiority analysis evaluating intubation rates, length of stay and mortality comparing HFNC and NIV. Though the etiology of respiratory failure was not known in the raw data, the non-inferiority analysis of the study show how HFNC may be beneficial in acute respiratory failure when NIV is not tolerated.


    Brief Overview: In 18 studies comparing HFNC alone with NIV or conventional oxygen therapy (COT), a total of 3,881 patients (from a variety of practice environments) were analyzed for differences in intubation, ICU mortality, and length of stay. Between HFNC and NIV, no statistically significant difference was found for ICU mortality and intubation rates; however, there was significant statistical heterogeneity.


    Limitations: There was significant heterogeneity possibly secondary to the lack of raw information; specifically, there was not data on the underlying cause of the respiratory failure. The study populations varied and included perioperative or cardiothoracic surgery patients in addition to ED patients. Furthermore, blinding interventions is obviously difficult to perform.


    Take Home Points: Despite significant heterogeneity, the analysis found that HFNC had benefit in avoiding intubation compared to COT. No difference was found in intubation rates when comparing HFNC and NIV. It may be worth an attempt at high flow nasal cannula to avoid intubation rather than conventional oxygen therapy in patients not able to tolerate NIV.


    Thanks to Zack Kuschner for the academic discussion on the topic and to Jackie Paulis for the artistic inspiration. Happy St. Patrick’s Day!



    1. Monro-Somerville T, Sim M, Ruddy J, Vilas M, Gillies MA. The Effect of High-Flow Nasal Cannula Oxygen Therapy on Mortality and Intubation Rate in Acute Respiratory Failure: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. Crit Care Med. 2017;45(4):e449-e456.
    • Welcome! This is the website for the Mount Sinai Emergency Ultrasound Division. It serves as an information resource for residents, fellows, medical students and others seeking information about point-of-care ultrasound. There is a lot ofRead more

    • Slow down your tachycardia (but not really)

      You’re sitting in resus bemoaning the departure of your most beloved attending when suddenly a patient wheels in without warning. The patient looks relatively stable but the triage RN tells you her heart rate wasRead more

    • Otitis externa: use the ear wick!

      Acute otitis externa (AOE) is a common complaint seen in pediatric as well as adult emergency departments. AOE is typically not accompanied by acute otitis media, although concurrent cases are possible. Also called “swimmer’s ear”Read more

    • Reach for the COWS

      Your patient in intake is miserable. Doubled over, complaining of pain everywhere, sweating, ill-appearing but not unstable. He tells you that the last time he used heroin was two nights ago, and he is askingRead more

    • Tis the season, summer edition

      As the late spring rains have begun to fade and the temperature rises mercilessly into the 80s and beyond, summer is finally upon us. And with summer comes a host of diseases for the emergencyRead more

    • Meet the newest member of your team

      We have a new resource in the Sinai ED. Say hello to your friendly ED pharmacist. In the past several years, the ED pharmacy has been centralized in a non-ED location. We all know wellRead more

    • In the spirit of roasts and fire-breathing dragons

      You’re on a lovely amble through the backcountry when suddenly you see smoke rising nearby and catch a whiff of a familiar scent that throws you back to your med school OR days: burning flesh.Read more

    • E-point Septal Separation in the Patient with Congestive Heart Failure

      Perhaps never explained so clearly, Cisewki and Alerhand’s article on EPSS is a wonderful read. Bottom line to remember: EPSS > 7 mm was 87% sensitive and 75% specific at identifying reduced EF (<50%).  This isRead more

    • Lidocaine for cough?

      Whether it’s asthma, a U.R.I., or post nasal drip as the cause, cough is a common enough complaint encountered by emergency physicians everywhere. Of course you must always rule out the dangerous causes of coughRead more